On the drive home from a business trip my colleagues and I were discussing movies. I love how that sentence makes it sound like I’m all grown up. And on that topic of being grown up we got to the topic of whether it can be socially acceptable for grown men to cry at movies. I was willing to test the waters right away and declare that yep, I cry during some films. And the mockery that ensued suggests that that social norms don’t yet welcome it.
Not that I don’t like the mockery – I welcome it. I’m sufficiently comfortable in my own skin to admit what I admitted, as well I am sufficiently comfortable to mock those whose list is even longer than this. I declared to the car there were 10 movies I cry during, and I said it in a way that made it sound like I confidently counted when in fact developing this list I found it wasn’t as easy as I thought. Not all 10 cause guaranteed tears, but all have resulted in my own personal Niagara Falls upon initial viewing, if not over multiple screenings.
Armageddon
The one that was first mentioned in the car, and the one that results in Duncan tears almost every time at the very end.
YouTube Clip at the very end of the film
The Iron Giant
I passionately believe that this is one of, if not the most underrated movies of all time. I love it and could not possibly recommend it enough. Sadly, few people have seen it, and if you are one of them make an point to catch it the next time you rent a movie or are on iTunes.
The Fellowship of the Ring
I believe this is my favourite of the three Lord of the Rings films, although really I tend to judge them as a single really long movie. The climax in particular is quite touching, and sets up a great adventure in the second and third acts.
The Return of the King
Bookending the climax of the first film is the climax of the third film. Now including both these films was difficult because while I certainly know I had man tears in theatres for both, I do not continue to cry today when I watch. But don’t let that take away from the fact that I think the ending is both emotional and fitting.
The Patriot
I don’t especially like this Mel Gibson film about the American Revolution and there isn’t much that is special about it, even with the presence of a young Heath Ledger, but there is a scene with Gibson’s character and his daughter that really gets me everytime. It is unlikely many will see the film if they haven’t already, so I’ll spoil away – the daughter stopped speaking before the film starts after her mom passed, and as Gibson’s character leaves to go to war again she breaks out in tears and begs him not to go. Sniff.
YouTube clip – go to 1:35 to see the scene I’m talking about
Braveheart
A much better Gibson film, and one where there are multiple tugs on my tear ducts. I would also imagine given the nature of the film, an appropriate example of when it is ok for men to cry in a film.
The Shawshank Redemption
As a now popular film on video, then on cable television I imagine almost all of you readers have seen it, but if you haven’t go get it. The very, very end gets me briefly each viewing, but far more accurate to say I choke up rather than let go completely.
Big Fish
If you are a man who has a Dad and loves him at all, it is hard to watch and not feel something at the climax. Toronto Mike has a great rundown on why it makes guys cry, so I won’t rehash it, rather just link.
Schindler’s List
As I am not made of stone, it wasn’t until the third or fourth viewing that this film didn’t cause me to reach for the kleenex. I also have decided this movie, one of my favourites, is a standard bearer for two other World War II films that cause me to come close to tears – the Pianist and Saving Private Ryan. All three are worth checking out.
Passion of the Christ
I wonder if it is Mel Gibson who is the common link here… in any case, the scene where Jesus falls while carrying the cross and Mary comes to help him up chokes me up – it is a well-crafted moment in what otherwise is a difficult and almost disturbing movie to watch. If you haven’t seen it, I would suggest Martin Scorsese’s The Last Temptation of Christ over this film, which is a much more intelligent and thought-provoking (not to mention enjoyable) version of Christ’s last days prior to crucifixion.
Hotel Rwanda. I don’t think I saw half the movie through clear eyes.
[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Allie Wojtaszek, Duncan Wojtaszek. Duncan Wojtaszek said: So I admit it, I cry during some films. Here is the list of 10 films I reliably cry during: http://bit.ly/duncantears [...]
Hotel Rwanda is bizarrely absent from the list of movies I’ve seen – and I don’t have a great reason to justify that. I love Don Cheadle, I know I’d like to see the movie. Something to add to my must-watch list.
Field of Dreams and Rudy would be top of my list, I think. Also Dances With Wolves. “YOU WILL ALWAYS BE MY FRIEND!” Whew. Choked up just writing that.
Field of Dreams.
The Truman Show. Every time. At the end, when he leaves for his new life and you’re just so happy for him.
Also, the opening of the new Star Trek movie (I know!) when Poppa Kirk dies.
And the Wrath of Khan, “Jim … out of danger?”
“I never took the Kobayshi Maru test. What do you think … of my solution.”
Nice list, well done.
Apart from chick flicks which’ll get me every time, the one that gets me crying everytime is “Life is Beautiful” with Roberto Benigni.
I didn’t cry in either Field of Dreams or Rudy, although both caused the man grim face about to cry look – I think it is a matter of when they were made, in that teenage period where I would have done anything not to be seen crying coupled with an apathy of being a teen. However both would have made a honourable mention, as should Life is Beautiful.
I didn’t like the Truman Show, and I’ve never cried at a Star Trek movie. I might have in Khan if I didn’t already know Spock would be back when I saw it.
Other ones I toyed with adding were Old Yeller (I’m sure I cried, but I was about six – I didn’t when I watched at 19) and the Phantom Menace when people start talking about midicholrians, because I love Star Wars and it just isn’t fair what Lucas did when he toyed around with that.
“Phantom Menace when people start talking about midicholrians, because I love Star Wars and it just isn’t fair what Lucas did when he toyed around with that.”
QFT.
I just cried through Episodes 1-3. Actually, Vader summarized my feelings at the end of the third… “Nooooooooooooooooooooooo”